Non Fatal:
Less Than Lethal Weapons and the Physics Behind Them


Home
Blunt Force
Electroshock
Chemical
Riot Control
References


Blunt Force

tactical_pen
An example of a "military" or "tactical" pen with glass breaker.
 

For many people, blunt force is the simplest, easiest, and cheapest self defense they will ever need. But why is it so effective? Why not just learn martial arts and call it good? In fact, according to Cindy Bir, a Bio-medical Engineer at Wayne State University, the average boxer is capable of throwing punches with almost 5,000 newtons of force behind them! And that's just their upper body! The same sample group Bir used was also capable of throwing 9,000 newton kicks! That's roughly half the energy in a standard 55 grain .223 Remington bullet at the muzzle of the rifle! That force dissipates with time and gravity as well!

This is a great point as it also disproves itself with Newton's Third Law: For every action, there is an opposite and equal reaction. That same 5,000 N force from the punch that the boxer threw also reflected back onto the boxer as a normal force. Now, boxers train to be able to throw hard punches, but they also wrap their hands during training as well as wearing padded gloves in the ring. Why? To give their hands a bit of cushioning. Otherwise the normal force of the punch would most likely break the boxer's hands! look at the following diagram:

punch_force

Force Diagram of Boxer punching a sand bag

As you can most likely tell, the glove will compress and act as a cushion, reducing the force of the punch, and thus reducing normal force, to ensure that no bones break. However, throwing a proper punch requires a lot more technique than most people know, and while most people can throw one with ease, their hand will not like them afterward even with significant padding.

Another problem is that regardless of how much force we put behind an attack, the human body will almost always cushion somewhat due to the nature of bio-organic materials. They are also prone to breakage when exposed to shot bursts of extreme force, surrendering the usefulness of bone's surprising compression strength.

This is where blunt force objects come in. Now, this could be anything from a stick to a hammer to a pool cue to a even pen. The primary purpose of a blunt force objects is to allow the person to use their full strength with less repercussions on the body. They are typically easy to manipulate, and are made of a material harder and usually more dense than human bio-mass. They also tend to be small or have a narrow striking surface, such as the pen at the top of the page, to increase pressure at a smaller area. This results in a tool that allows someone to focus the force behind their strikes to ensure maximum effectiveness.

pressure
Pressure of an elbow striking an object vs pressure of a pen tip striking an object

Shotguns and rifles can also take advantage of blunt force with special ammunition that uses a beanbag or rubber for a projectile. These are most often employed by police to incapacitate violent suspect. In this application, it is ideal for the ammunition to have a larger striking face to prevent the round from entering the target and causing severe damage.

beanbag_rounds 
Less than lethal shotgun rounds.
It should be noted that while blunt force objects are the easiest to obtain, they are also very easy to mishandle, resulting in fatal injuries to the user and target. Blunt force objects, as with any less than lethal weapons, should be used only to incapacitate the threat and as a means to get to safety unless there is no other options.

Javier De Leon
Physics 211 - Fall 2018
University of Alaska Fairbanks
Background: "Blue" by karenatsharon is licensed under CC BY 2.0