Although neither Mr.
Jackson nor Mr. Robinson are likely very appreciative of my fascination
with this hit, I do sincerely claim that this particular collision
makes for a very interesting physics discussion. What makes it
interesting is the fact that both players are very similar in both
height, weight, and speed. Also unusual, as you can see in the
video, this particular collision is completely direct, in other words
there is no horizontal rotational motion by either player that would
otherwise reduce the effects of the applied force during the hit.
You may also have noticed that there is a vertical rotational motion
made by Desean Jackson where his torso is violently propelled in the
opposite direction that he was traveling in just a half-second before,
we will look at this closer a bit later. |
According to NFL.com,
Desean Jackson is 5' 10'' tall, weighing 175 pounds, and during the
scouting combine he completed the 40 yard dash in 4.29 seconds.
Dunta Robinson is listed at 5' 11'' tall, weighing 186 pounds, and he
completed the 40 yard dash in 4.34 seconds. This is enough
information to get a rough approximation of the force exerted on Desean
Jackson during the collision using Newton's famous second law: Force
equals mass times acceleration (F=ma). |
First, we can
approximate Jackson's speed during the play using his forty yard dash
time: |
Second, we can find
Jackson's mass from his listed weight: |
Third, we can find
Jackson's acceleration (a.k.a. his change in velocity) if we estimate
his velocity immediately after the collision to be approximately 0
m/s. Dr. Timothy Gay, in his book The Physics of Football, states
that the typical tackle has a duration of two-tenths of a second.
Taking into consideration that Jackson's velocity decreases from 8.53
m/s to 0 m/s in 0.2 seconds we have thus found Jackson's acceleration (
or rather deceleration) during the collision: |
Finally, now that we
have determined Jackson's mass and acceleration, we can determine the
force he encountered by simply taking the product of the two: 3400 Newtons is a very impressive amount of force, in fact it's enough to cause Jackson's head and helmet to accelerate at a rate that is over a hundred times the acceleration of gravity. In an article for Popular Mechanics, Matt Higgins describes a "100-g impact" as fairly commonplace in football, with extreme impacts registering over 150 g's. |
Newton's Third Law
tells us that Desean Jackson applies just as much force to Dunta
Robinson as Robinson does to Jackson, which is fairly obvious from the
video considering that both players appear semi-conscious at best as
they are being helped off of the field. The following video has an excellent chance to better your understanding of Newton's Third Law and momentum in football. |