Allied Tank Guns: The American
M1 and the British QF 17-Pounder
Now we can move on to the Allied
tank weapons of World War II. The Allies were not
very strong when it comes to steel warfare. They
relied on a lot of units that would out flank the
Germans and hit them from the tanks weaker points.
The British did have a solution and
they called it the "Tiger Killer". As previously
stated, the Tiger I was nearly impenetrable when
it came to the Allied tanks. The M4 Sherman tank
could not get penetrate with its weak M1 cannon.
The British decided to mount their own 17-Pounder
cannon on an M4 Sherman and this changed how the
Allies fought the war of armor.
First we will start of with the
American M1 cannon. Pictured below is the 76mm M1
cannon that is mounted on an M4 Sherman.
The M1 cannon was
actually an improvement from the earlier M3 75mm
cannon. The M1 was capable of taking out lightly
armored targets such as the Panzer IV's. But when
Nazi Germany introduced the Tiger I, everything
changed.
Relative to the German
Tiger I's and Tiger II's, The M1 cannon was not
very impressive. The only advantage that it had
was that it was mounted on a reliable, fast tank
that could easily maneuver around the enemy and
strike.
Now we will go into
the physics of the M1 cannon.
APBC:
The M1
cannon had the M62 shell as their main armament.
It had a mass of 7 kg with 0.065 kg of explosive
filler. This totals up to 7.065 kg of projectile.
If you remember from the Tiger I, it's APBC round
had a much higher mass, coming in at 10.20 kg. The
velocity of the projectile didn't help so much
either. It only came out of the barrel going 790
m/s. Using the kinetic energy equation, we can see
that the M1 APBC round only has 2,204,633 joules
of energy. Not even close enough to penetrate a
Tiger I from the front. This produces about 124mm
of penetration.
APCR:
The true
armor piercing round for the M1 cannon, the M79,
is slightly better. This round travels the same
speed as the APBC round, but also has more mass.
It comes in at 11 kg and travels at 790 m/s.
Determining kinetic energy, we find that it has
3,432,550 joules of energy, capable of penetrating
132mm of armor.
Because of the poor
statistics that were calculated above, the British
didn't want to adopt the M4 Sherman with its M1
cannon. So they chose to do something a bit
different and mount one of their guns on the M4
Sherman platform. Pictured below, this is the
result: the Sherman Firefly.
As you can see in the
two different pictures, the Firefly has a much
longer barrel, promoting muzzle velocity. This gun
gave the Germans a surprise when they went up
against it. Looking like the traditional American
Sherman, the Germans had no idea that it was
capable of taking out the mighty Tiger I.
This is why the QF
17-Pounder cannon was a game changer.
APBC:
Being the
most controversial round of the war, the APBC
round that the QF 17-Pounder had was incredible.
Having a mass of 7.71 kg and a speed of 884 m/s,
It could penetrate 174mm of armor, easily
destroying Tiger I tanks. The energy that it had
was 3,012,512 joules. Because it was traveling
very fast, it could penetrate German armor very
well.
There was no immediate
need for an APCR round because the QF 17-Pounder
APBC round did very well.